I've done a post on this book before, but I just reread it recently and it just amazes me to find that I forgot how incredibly well written this book is.
Every day at midnight this person who calls him/herself A changes to a different body (I should just say right now that I'm going to try to avoid using gender differentiating pronouns when I'm talking about A unless I'm referring to the body that A is in. So some sentences will seem strange). It has been this way for as long as A can remember. A always tries to leave the person's life A has borrowed for a day as close to the same as possible. But then A meets a girl named Rhiannon. A meets her for the first time as her boyfriend Justin. A can sense that she is unhappy with Justin, but she won't admit it. So A feels compelled to give her one amazing day even though A knows that that isn't the kind of thing Justin would do. They skip school to go to the beach and they spend the whole day there.
But then the next day A wakes up as Leslie Wong, and the day after that as Skylar Smith, and then as Amy Tran. Throughout all of these days A can't get Rhiannon out of A's mind. So on this particular day A gets a crazy idea. A decides that A is going to go to Rhiannon's school and pretend that Amy Tran's parents want to move to that town and that if they do she would be going to school there, and she just wanted to see what it was like. So Rhiannon suggests that Amy comes with her to all of her classes that day, and by just suggesting that, A falls in love with her even more that A already is. So they spend the day together and Rhiannon has no idea that the person she spends her day with is the same person who was her uncharacteristically sweet and caring boyfriend just three days before.
The next day A wakes up in the body of a drug addict. A refuses to give in to the body's demands to get high again. This day A thinks about how so many people who do drugs think that they have control over it, and that the body is just a vessel rather than something that has its own needs. A thinks about how eventually there comes a time when the body takes over and dictates how that person lives their life. And I think that seems entirely accurate. You start to lose sight of yourself when you're always thinking about where you can get that next fix.
The next day A is in the body of Nathan Daldry. And while A was Justin, A remembered his e-mail address and password and this day A decides to log on to it and finds that there is a party that night that Justin and probably Rhiannon are going to. So A makes Nathan lie to his parents and tell them that he's going to a musical, but really A is going to a party an hour and a half away. When A gets there A sees Rhiannon standing by a CD rack looking at what music is there. A walks over to her and starts a conversation with her. A tells her that Nathan is a gay cousin of Steve Mason who is the host of the party. They start dancing and they dance the whole night. They dance until 11:15pm when the police show up due to a noise complaint. This is very bad for A because at midnight A will be ripped from Nathan's body and shoved into the next, and it is painful when A is awake and that happens. So A drives until 11:50 and finally pulls over to the side of the road to try to sleep so it won't be as painful when midnight comes. A gives Rhiannon an e-mail address that A makes up on the spot to fit Nathan's name before A leaves though. The next day A makes that account and sends an e-mail to Rhiannon. Then when A checks A's old e-mail there is a threatening and hostile message from the real Nathan Daldry. A realises that A must have forgotten to clear the history on Nathan's computer when A was done checking A's e-mail the day before. A isn't sure how to respond or even if A should so A doesn't for the time being.
Then eventually Rhiannon finds out that Steve doesn't have a gay cousin named Nathan and she calls A out on that. A decides that A will meet up with her and tell her some lie that will cover who A wants her to believe A really is, but A can't think of a convincing lie so A decides that A will try to tell her the truth in hopes that maybe she will be able to accept it. At first Rhiannon is skeptical and really just doesn't believe that A is telling the truth, but A thinks of a way to prove it to her. A suggests that they meet up again the next day, A as a different person of course and A will tell her all the things A knows and remembers about her; things only A would know from the times they've met.
Through all of this, the drama with Nathan grows. Nathan claims that the day A had control of his body it was the devil that convinced him to lie to his parents and go to that party. He also keeps e-mailing A with questions and demands to be answered. He keeps being interviewed and his story keeps spreading to cities farther from his own.
Rhiannon starts to come around and believes that A is telling the truth about changing bodies everyday when they meet up again and A tells her all the things A knows about her.
One day A is in the body of Kelsea Cook. A is knowledgeable about mental illness and A knows how some people think that it is a matter of mood or personality and a person who has mental illness chooses to be that way. But A knows otherwise. Depression and OCD and anxiety disorders are all a manifestation of the body and different chemicals involved. A has been in the bodies of people with mental illness before and probably will at some point again And this particular day A lives as Kelsea Cook, a girl who is severely depressed and suicidal. A does all A can to differentiate between A's own thoughts and Kelsea's depressed thoughts. Then when A opens Kelsea's journal A finds that it is unlike any journal A has seen before. It is not filled with thoughts on classmates or teachers or her father. There are no musings about her day or secrets hidden away. This journal is filled with ways to kill yourself in extraordinary detail. At the end of it all is a deadline that is six days into the future. A decides right away to talk to Rhiannon about it. A e-mails her and tells her that Kelsea wants to kill herself. A gives Rhiannon Kelsea's phone number and Rhiannon calls her. They talk on the phone for a little while and then Rhiannon suggests that she goes to Kelsea's so they can figure this out. Rhiannon thinks that A should talk to Kelsea's father and tell him that she is depressed and wants to kill herself. A is hesitant about this idea at first because it's so out of the realm of anything A has ever done before to interfere in someone's life. A's motto more or less is to leave the lives the way A found them, the purposeful exception involving Rhiannon and the accidental exception being Nathan. In the end, A decides that this is a time that interfering would be beneficial to Kelsea, so at dinner that night A tells Kelsea's father that she wants to kill herself and that they need to get her some help. A says that the next day they need to go to a therapist and start on the path to recovery. And even if the next day she refuses wanting help or ever telling him that he has to force her to go, whatever it takes to get her help. And then a few days later Rhiannon calls Kelsea's house again and tells her father that she's a friend from school and wants to talk to Kelsea. Her father says that she's not home, and that she's going to be away for a while, so A and Rhiannon make the assumption that that means she is getting help.
Meanwhile, Nathan is becoming more insistent with his demand for answers and the only one A allows is that A is not the devil.
Then next time A and Rhiannon meet, A is in the body of a beautiful black girl named Ashley Ashton. It's the weekend so Rhiannon and A spend the day together. Eventually talk turns to Justin. A believes that Justin will never love her or care for her as much as A does, and A believes that if Justin met A in Ashley's body he would be drooling over her. And Rhiannon takes this as a challenge and calls Justin and asks him to have dinner with her and meet one of her friends. He says yes and like A thought Justin takes one look at Ashley and is struck dumb by her beauty. A flirts with him and hopes that he flirts back to prove A's point to Rhiannon. And while Rhiannon is in the washroom A suggests to Justin that they do something together without Rhiannon, but Justin senses the trap and refuses, knowing that A is being too forward with him. Rhiannon ends up getting very angry at A and doesn't respond to A for a while after that.
A decides to go to Rhiannon's school the next day to talk to her. They talk about Justin and why he didn't take the bait that A threw at him and A thought it was only because he sensed the trap.
After that day though Rhiannon suggests that they don't meet up for a while, she says she just wants to stick to e-mail for a while. So they can both have a chance to think things through. Then after a few bland and distracted days for A, things change. Every morning the first thing A accesses is how far away A is from Rhiannon. And after a few days of not seeing her A realises that A IS her for the day. A tries to access as little about Rhiannon A's A can. In the morning when A gets Rhiannon ready for school A doesn't shower or look at Rhiannon's body as A gets dressed. Even brushing her hair and putting make up on her feels too intimate to A. But A does it and A tries A's best to live the day as Rhiannon would want A to. A has lunch with Justin and afterwards Justin kisses Rhiannon, and A is shocked at how the same two people kissing feels so different in the different bodies. When A was Justin that kiss felt like fireworks, but when A is Rhiannon it feels as though something alien is pressed against her lips. A decides that after school A will take Rhiannon to the mountains and just enjoy the day. After that, near the end of the day A writes Rhiannon a letter about the day and how if A had the choice A would never have chosen to be in her body.
The next day A gets an e-mail from Rhiannon suggesting that they meet up to talk in person about the day before. Once they have Rhiannon asks A again about whether A feels like a girl or a boy, and whether A felt more at home in her body than A would have in the body of a boy. A just tells her that A always feels at home and at the same time A never feels at home.
Meanwhile, Nathan is still demanding answers but it seems that nothing A gives him is good enough.
The next day that A is able to meet up with Rhiannon A is in the body of a boy named George who is homeschooled. The only way A is able to get away is by asking his mom if he can go to the library to get books on the stuff that they're learning. So George's mom drops him off at the library where A meets Rhiannon. They go to a restaurant and eat and then go back to the library. But when George's mom comes to pick him up she sees him kissing Rhiannon. A gets George into a lot of trouble for that too.
The next weekend A and Rhiannon make plans to spend the weekend together. Rhiannon directs A to a little cabin in the woods owned by her uncle. They get very close to making love but A stops her because A knows that she wants this body that A is in right now but that all may change by the next day. So A tells her that A doesn't want to have sex. A leaves before midnight and promises to be back the next day, but the next day A is in the body of a girl named Dana, and Dana is grounded. She also has a massive hangover that's so bad that A can't even access what she did that got her grounded. Eventually, A is told what happened the night before by a doctor that makes a house call and finds out that Dana tried to drive home extremely drunk. Her parents were called and she nearly ran her father over. Then the doctor brings up her brother Anthony and A realises that Dana killed her brother by driving drunk with him in the passenger seat. And by the end of the day A wasn't able to see Rhiannon. A wasn't even able to tell her that A wouldn't be able to come to the cabin that day. The next day A plans to get up early and e-mail her with the full explanation, but A is woken up by Michael's mother and is told that they are going to Hawaii. But A can't leave and go to Hawaii because by the time Michael gets back from vacation A will be in the body of someone else and A won't be able to get back to Rhiannon unless A goes into another person leaving Hawaii and going to the states. A can't travel over bodies of water so if A goes to Hawaii A could be there for months, even years. So A leaves a note for Michael's family saying that he can't go to Hawaii today and that he's sorry. A goes to Rhiannon's school to find her seriously pissed off. A tells her that A was stuck in Dana's room and there was no way of getting out of the house unnoticed let alone taking a car. But Rhiannon is still pissed off and rightly so because while she was waiting for A to get there some of her uncle's hunting buddies came up there and proceeded to gut a deer right in front of her. And she didn't think she could leave because she was still expecting A to show up. When the first hunter showed up she thought it was A and she was dressed provocatively for A, but then instead of A it was an eighty year old man who thought she was trespassing. He only believed that she was related to her Uncle Artie because they have the same last name.
A tries to comfort her by giving her a hug when Justin shows up and sees. Justin starts beating up A and verbally attacking Rhiannon. And A has to leave Rhiannon there crying or else be beat up some more or arrested for trespassing on the school property. A and Rhiannon meet up later that day and they talk about how uncertain everything is in their relationship. They understand that the only thing they can do is to hope that they will see each other then next day, but they learn not to expect it. A also finds out that Rhiannon and Justin are now broken up, and that's not the way that either of them wanted it to happen but they know that it is ultimately for the best, even if Rhiannon doesn't end up with A. When A gets back to Michael's house his father is there waiting for him. Michael's father says that they were able to get flight tickets for the next day luckily, but that Michael would be grounded when they got there.
The next day that A and Rhiannon see each other A is a guy who weighs over 300 pounds. A can tell that Rhiannon is put off by this and she is shocked to see A so different from anything she's seen before. They have a good time hanging out that day but A knows that Rhiannon isn't having as good of a time as she would if A wasn't fat.
The next day, Rhiannon e-mails A and tells A that she wants to see A today and follows it up with "We need to talk." When they meet up she tells A that she doesn't think she can keeping doing what they're doing. She finds it all too weird and uncertain. A proposes that when they're both old enough, they could go to New York or some other big city where there are a lot of people closer together so that A would be closer to her more often. But Rhiannon doesn't go for it. She just doesn't think she's strong enough to go through with it. She still wants A in her life, but she doesn't want to be in a relationship.
The next day, A gets another e-mail from Nathan still asking for answers so A agrees to meet up with him and give him some, The thing is though, A told Nathan that A's name is Andrew and on this day, A is a girl. A thinks this is a good thing because it will help to illustrate A's point. So A meets up with Nathan at a restaurant and A tells him the truth. Nathan promises to keep it a secret, but the next day A meets up with him again, this time at his house. A gets there and thinks that only the two of them are there but then the Reverend who Nathan has been turning to for support ends up being there. He is threatening and A tries to leave but Reverend Poole blocks A's way out. the Reverend tells A that there are others like A, and he implies that he is like A. The only difference is that the Reverend - or rather the person who's taken over the Reverend's body and mind - has learned how to stay in a body for more than just a day. This peaks A's interest obviously, but not enough for A to forget about the malevolent gleam in his eyes. A eventually is able to get away, but A is still thinking about what the Reverend said and how it could change everything for A, or it could change nothing. A decides that A can't go back to Reverend Poole to figure out how to stay in one body for more than a day. A decides that if A did that it would be murder.
One day, A wakes up as Alexander Lin, who is a kind-hearted, and truthful person. A decides to meet up with Rhiannon, and when she gets there A suggests that they pretend this is the first time they've met. Rhiannon decides to go along with this, and they decide to have dinner together at Alexander's house. First, they go to a grocery store and get some stuff and then they go to Alexander's. The house is empty because Alexander's parents are out of town. They eat dinner in Alexander's tree house. Rhiannon says that she should call her mom and tell her that she's eating dinner at a friend's house, and A tells her to say she's spending the night. She's hesitant at first, but she agrees.
When A explains why A thought she should spend the night A tells her that there might be a way for A to stay but that A will never be able to stay. Rhiannon gets mad at this, but A tells her that A wants her to be with Alexander. That's why this is the first time they met. A doesn't want Alexander to forget anything from that day. A believes that Rhiannon will be able to find the things she finds in A, also in Alexander.
So they spend the night together, they fall asleep together and the next day Rhiannon wakes up next to Alexander. A wakes up and A runs.
It doesn't say where A runs to, or how far anything. I just says that A runs. I kind of wish the book went further, and told us what happens to A after A runs and where A runs to. But I get why David Levithan left it there. Some things need to be left to the imagination, for some people maybe A ran off to New York just because A liked the idea of possibly staying in the same city for a while, even if it would be in a different body everyday, or maybe A ran off to Hawaii or California. The magic is in not knowing for sure where A is.
I also just want to share a quote from this book that I Found to be extremely enlightening and profoundly true, and it is this: “If there's one thing I've learned, it's this: We all want everything to be okay. We don't even wish so much for fantastic or marvelous or outstanding. We will happily settle for okay, because most of the time, okay is enough.”
One day, A wakes up as Alexander Lin, who is a kind-hearted, and truthful person. A decides to meet up with Rhiannon, and when she gets there A suggests that they pretend this is the first time they've met. Rhiannon decides to go along with this, and they decide to have dinner together at Alexander's house. First, they go to a grocery store and get some stuff and then they go to Alexander's. The house is empty because Alexander's parents are out of town. They eat dinner in Alexander's tree house. Rhiannon says that she should call her mom and tell her that she's eating dinner at a friend's house, and A tells her to say she's spending the night. She's hesitant at first, but she agrees.
When A explains why A thought she should spend the night A tells her that there might be a way for A to stay but that A will never be able to stay. Rhiannon gets mad at this, but A tells her that A wants her to be with Alexander. That's why this is the first time they met. A doesn't want Alexander to forget anything from that day. A believes that Rhiannon will be able to find the things she finds in A, also in Alexander.
So they spend the night together, they fall asleep together and the next day Rhiannon wakes up next to Alexander. A wakes up and A runs.
It doesn't say where A runs to, or how far anything. I just says that A runs. I kind of wish the book went further, and told us what happens to A after A runs and where A runs to. But I get why David Levithan left it there. Some things need to be left to the imagination, for some people maybe A ran off to New York just because A liked the idea of possibly staying in the same city for a while, even if it would be in a different body everyday, or maybe A ran off to Hawaii or California. The magic is in not knowing for sure where A is.
I also just want to share a quote from this book that I Found to be extremely enlightening and profoundly true, and it is this: “If there's one thing I've learned, it's this: We all want everything to be okay. We don't even wish so much for fantastic or marvelous or outstanding. We will happily settle for okay, because most of the time, okay is enough.”